Dear Melodies vs BeatJar: an honest comparison
On its homepage, dearmelodies.com shows $33.40 and $62.00. Both are plans that renew every 4 or 8 weeks until you cancel. It has a 4.8 Trustpilot score from 635 reviews, and its policies call payments "generally final". Before you pay, BeatJar lets you read every lyric and plays the start of your song, from US$37.95.
Checked 18 Oct 2026 8 min read Unverified claims left out
Renewal comes with every Dear Melodies plan. Here you read every lyric and hear your song first, then pay for that one song.
Read the lyrics and hear a preview before you pay
Press play: a real BeatJar song, written from a customer story
Anniversary · for a husband
A country anniversary song for the man she met at Fenway
Country · Celebratory · Female vocal
What they wrote: This is our 20th wedding anniversary. We met on match.com and fell in love at Fenway Park. We have a son and a daughter. We love to go...
Story, lyrics and the songWho each one is for
Both turn a few details into a finished song in days. They differ in how you pay and what you see first.
Pick BeatJar if
- You want to read every lyric and hear your song before paying
- You want to pay for one song, not start a plan that renews
- You want the MP3 included in the price
- You want free revisions after delivery
- You want a refund or remake path for real errors, in writing
Pick Dear Melodies if
- You want several songs over a few weeks, and the plan price per song suits you
- You are happy to enter your story in their app after paying
- You want rush delivery as a paid option
- You want the choice of genres such as ballad, acoustic, pop and country
- A 4.8 score from 635 Trustpilot reviews matters to you
Dear Melodies vs BeatJar: which should you pick?
Pick BeatJar if you want to pay once for one song, and pick Dear Melodies if you want several songs on a renewing plan. Dear Melodies lists $33.40 every 4 weeks and $62.00 every 8 weeks, and both plans renew until you cancel. Its refund policy calls payments "generally final and non-refundable", and you buy the plan before you enter your story. Its Trustpilot score is 4.8 from 635 reviews, so many customers are happy. BeatJar starts at US$37.95 for one song, MP3 included. Every lyric appears word for word, and the first 45 seconds of your own song plays before you pay. If a real error slips through, a refund or remake is available within 48 hours of delivery. Revisions after delivery are free, and checkout lets you choose delivery between about an hour and 24 hours.
Side by side
Figures for Dear Melodies come from dearmelodies.com, its terms, privacy and refund policies, and Trustpilot on 18 October 2026.
| BeatJar | Dear Melodies | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | US$37.95 | $33.40 every 4 weeks or $62.00 every 8 weeks, "auto renews" |
| What the price buys | One song, the MP3, the lyrics, revisions | Plans list "3 songs per 4 weeks" and lyrics; the 8-week plan adds a digital gift card and unlimited revisions |
| MP3 download | Included | FAQ: "a high-quality MP3 file to download and keep forever" |
| Hear it before paying | The first 45 seconds of your song | Homepage sample song, 3:27; you buy the plan, then enter your story |
| Read the lyrics before paying | ||
| Delivery | You choose at checkout | "Within 3 days"; rush for "an additional fee" |
| Revisions | Free and unlimited after delivery | "Unlimited revisions" listed on the 8-week plan only |
| Refund | You pay after the preview; refund or remake for real errors within 48 hours of delivery | "All payments are generally final and non-refundable"; refunds "assessed on a case-by-case basis" |
| Renewal and cancel | No plan to cancel | Renews until canceled; cancel "at least 48 hours before the next scheduled billing date" |
| Company | BeatJar | Moonway LLC, Dover, Delaware; platform owner "a company incorporated in the Republic of Cyprus" |
| Trustpilot | 4.9 from 1,050+ reviews | 4.8 from 635 reviews; 89% five-star, 3% one-star |
We entered no personal details and saw no checkout screens. This table leaves out introductory prices and add-ons such as rush delivery.
What Dear Melodies' own pages say
Quoted from their pages on 18 October 2026.
Price and billing
"Auto renews at $33.40 every 4 weeks"
What it means: The $33.40 is a plan that renews, not the price of one song. The 8-week plan renews at $62.00 every 8 weeks.
Cancelling
"you must cancel ... at least 48 hours before the next scheduled billing date."
What it means: Cancel two days early, or the next payment goes through.
Refunds
"all payments are generally final and non-refundable, except as required by applicable law or as expressly stated in this Policy or in the specific offer presented to you at checkout."
What it means: Expect no refund unless the law or your checkout offer says otherwise.
Delivery
"We deliver your finished song within 3 days of receiving your completed form. Rush delivery options are available for an additional fee if you need it sooner."
What it means: Plan on up to three days. Faster delivery costs extra.
AI disclosure
"Some Services may rely on third-party artificial intelligence systems, models, APIs, databases, hosting providers, infrastructure providers, or other technical providers."
What it means: Terms of service name AI systems as one possible tool, and none of the pages we read says who sings your song.
How does Dear Melodies work?
Dear Melodies sells plans, not single songs. Per the homepage, the order runs "Purchase a plan, share your story in the app, and receive a heartfelt melody." You pay first and write your story second. $33.40 buys the 4-week plan and $62.00 the 8-week plan. Both list "3 songs per 4 weeks", and both renew until you cancel. The button reads "Start My Plan", and the page says you can cancel in your account settings.
Cancelling stops future renewals but gives no automatic refund for money already paid. Uninstalling the app leaves the plan running.
What do Dear Melodies' terms say about refunds and AI?
The refund policy sets a strict default: no refund for dissatisfaction when the service ran as described, and none for a missed renewal date. A refund is possible if the service failed through their fault or the company confirms a billing error. Meanwhile the homepage says "100% guaranteed", yet the policy never defines that guarantee.
An email brings a private link and, per the FAQ, an MP3 to keep. The homepage calls each song "crafted from scratch". Section 11.3 of the terms mentions third-party AI systems, and none of the pages we read says who sings.
What happens when you order from BeatJar?
You type the story. We write the lyrics and show them to you. Then we play the first 45 seconds of your song before you pay anything. You can change any lyric line before we record it, or walk away. When it sounds right, you pay from US$37.95 for that song, and the MP3 is included: download it, share it with family, play it at the party. Revisions stay free after delivery, and you pick the delivery window at checkout. 30,800+ songs have gone out this way, rated 4.9 on Trustpilot from 1,050+ reviews.
Which Facebook pages run the Dear Melodies ads?
On 18 October 2026 the Meta Ad Library showed more than 500 active ads for dearmelodies.com, the point where the library count stops. Of those, 289 started in the last 30 days. The ads run on several Facebook pages named for single people, among them "Elara Whitmore", "Ella Dawson" and "Beau Walker Music". One more page goes by "Dear Melodies Music". If an ad from one of those pages brought you here, its link goes to dearmelodies.com.
Read every lyric and hear the start of your song. It costs nothing until you like it.
Read the lyrics and hear a preview before you pay
What customers say they wish was different about Dear Melodies
From 15 Dear Melodies reviews at three stars or below on Trustpilot (12 one-star, 3 three-star, all we found on 18 October 2026), grouped by theme and paraphrased. A review can sit in more than one theme. Their positive reviews, 96% of 635, praise how moving the song was and how easy ordering felt.
7 of 15
Did not expect the charges: a monthly bill after one song, repeat charges, or paying extra to fix something.
At BeatJar: you see one price before you start, pay only after the preview, and revisions after delivery are free.
6 of 15
Paid, but the song never arrived, hid somewhere in the app, or would not play.
At BeatJar: you hear the start of your own song before paying, and you choose the delivery window at checkout.
6 of 15
Support was hard to reach, went in circles, or two reviewers say answers came from an AI.
At BeatJar: every lyric and the first 45 seconds of your song come before payment, and a refund or remake covers real errors within 48 hours of delivery.
5 of 15
Had to pay again to fix a mistake or get a redo.
At BeatJar: you can change any lyric line before the recording, and revisions after delivery cost nothing.
3 of 15
The song ignored the brief: the wrong voice, or requested details left out.
At BeatJar: you read every lyric line and hear the first 45 seconds before you pay.
2 of 15
Arrived late, in one case a day late on a 6-hour order.
At BeatJar: you pick the delivery window at checkout: Express about an hour, standard within 24 hours.
What does Dear Melodies do better than BeatJar?
If you want several songs over a few weeks, the plan can cost less per song. At $33.40 for three songs, a customer who uses all three pays about $11 each. Per its policy, unused credits "do not carry over". The 4.8 Trustpilot score from 635 reviews is high, and the company replied to most of the low ratings we read. The FAQ promises an MP3 to keep. Styles include ballad, acoustic, pop and country. Anyone who cannot wait three days can pay for rush. A registered US company with a Delaware address stands behind it. Its 8-week plan lists unlimited revisions, which BeatJar also offers after delivery.
What should you check before ordering from either?
- "Start My Plan" begins a subscription that renews, so check the billing line at checkout.
- Cancel at least 48 hours before the next billing date, because deleting the app does not cancel.
- Read the refund policy first. Theirs says payments are "generally final", while BeatJar lets you hear the start of your song before you pay.
- Ask what changes cost. Several reviewers say fixing a mistake cost extra, and BeatJar revisions after delivery are free.
- Keep your receipt and email, since support asks for the email, date and amount if anything goes wrong.
Hear your song, then keep it
Every lyric and 45 seconds of your song come first, with the MP3 included from US$37.95. Only if it is right.
You read the lyrics and hear a preview before you pay.
Why people choose BeatJar
4.9/5 on Trustpilot · 30,800+ songs delivered
-
You hear it before you pay
Read every line, listen to a preview of your own song, then decide.
-
Nothing gets invented
The lyrics come from what you type. Leave something out and it stays out.
-
Free until it sounds right
Change a line, the feel or the voice. Revisions cost nothing.
-
Delivered when you need it
Pick the delivery window at checkout, from an hour to a day. Same-day is normal for us.
Questions people ask
How much does Dear Melodies cost?
Does Dear Melodies auto-renew?
Is Dear Melodies legit?
Can you hear a Dear Melodies song before you pay?
Does Dear Melodies use AI?
Why do I see Dear Melodies ads from pages with people's names?
What this is based on
Our own data for the numbers, Trustpilot for the reviews, published research for the rest.
Every number on this page
Our order records | Delivered songs, genres, voices, who they were for. Refreshed daily.
Every review on this page
Trustpilot | Quoted word for word from our public profile, never edited.
Homepage
Fetched 18 Oct 2026 from dearmelodies.com/en | Plans: "Auto renews at $33.40 every 4 weeks" and "Auto renews at $62.00 every 8 weeks"; "3-Day Delivery"; FAQ on MP3 and use.
Subscription and refund policy
Opened 18 Oct 2026 from dearmelodies.com/subscription-and-refund-policy | "all payments are generally final and non-refundable" (s7.1); auto-renewal (s3.1); cancel 48 hours before billing (s6.2).
Terms of service
Checked 18 Oct 2026 from dearmelodies.com/terms-of-service | Moonway LLC, Delaware (s1.1); Cyprus platform owner (s1.2); third-party AI (s11.3).
Privacy policy
Saved 18 Oct 2026 from dearmelodies.com/privacy-policy | Moonway LLC, 8 The Green, Suite B, Dover, Delaware 19901; [email protected].
Contact page
Pulled 18 Oct 2026 from dearmelodies.com/contact-us | Web form; [email protected] on the policies. No phone number found.
Trustpilot reviews
Viewed 18 Oct 2026 from trustpilot.com/review/dearmelodies.com | 4.8 from 635 reviews; 89% five-star, 3% one-star; themes above from the 15 reviews at three stars or below.
Where to go next
BeatJar reviews, word for word
Reviews | What our own customers say, and whether BeatJar is legit.
Dear Melodies review
Review | An honest Dear Melodies review: what $33.40 and $62.00 buy, how renewal and refunds work, what Trustpilot reviewers say, and whether it is legit.
Songfinch vs BeatJar
Compare | Songfinch prices, delivery, refunds and reviews next to BeatJar: a human artist from $179.99, or every lyric and 45 seconds of your song before you pay.
Unique Song vs BeatJar
Compare | Unique Song advertises $79 to $99 and a free preview. Lyrics cost extra, revisions are one round, refunds end at 24 hours. What their pages say, next to BeatJar.
Forever Songs vs BeatJar
Compare | ForeverSongs.com is $29 to stream a song on a private page; the MP3 download costs extra. What their pages say about price and previews, next to BeatJar.
Birthday songs for a mom
By occasion | The beach trips, the single-mom years, the windows-down drives. Real birthday songs made for mothers, and what to write.
Custom country songs
Genre | The genre more than half our customers choose. Real country songs made from real stories, and what to put in yours.
I forgot our anniversary. What now?
Moment | It is the day, or the day after, and you have nothing. What to say first, what you can still do tonight, and the gift that turns the forgetting into the story.
"I don't want anything." What to get them anyway
Moment | When someone says "do not get me anything", they mean objects. What they cannot refuse: proof that you noticed, in a letter, a day, or a song with their name in it.